Eastern Michigan University EMU HOME
 
About EMUFuture StudentsCurrent StudentsAcademics & ResearchFaculty & StaffAlumni & FriendsAthletics & RecreationNews & Events

[10.24-25.03] CIES Midwestern Regional Conference. Learn more...
 


Eastern Michigan University
Ypsilanti, MI, USA 48197

Website designed & maintained by Prasad Papudesi

104 John W. Porter
Ypsilanti MI 48197
Phone: 734 487 1060
Fax: 734 487 3312

 

Detroit Comer Schools

2001- 2002 Most Improved School

Peter G. Monnier Elementary School, Detroit, MI

What is the Detroit Comer School and Families Initiative?

The Comer Schools and Families Initiative is a collaborative effort that seeks to raise student achievement and promote healthy growth and development. This is achieved through the implementation of all components of the Yale Child Study Center's School Development Program in the Detroit Public Schools. The purpose of the initiative is to improve academic learning and to enhance the social, psychological and emotional development of students. Resources are focused on student needs in a comprehensive, collaborative school-based improvement process. The program requires the active involvement and support of all major school/community education stakeholders with emphasis on active parent involvement.

The collaborators in this initiative include the Detroit Public Schools, Detroit Federation of Teachers, Organization of School Administrators and Supervisors, City-Wide School Community Organization, Eastern Michigan University, The Skillman Foundation and Yale Child Study Center School Development Program.

What is Eastern Michigan University's role?

Project staffs from Eastern Michigan University, Yale University Child Study Center, and Detroit Public Schools run the regional Comer SDP collaboratively. Each school is treated as a unique entity with specific needs. To create meaningful change each school specifies target improvement areas, such as improving attendance, immunization compliance, and safety concerns. School development in the early stages of implementation focuses on staff development and linking schools with community agencies to provide needed resources. Ongoing programs for parental involvement and parent development prepare parents to become active in the process. By mid-implementation, the school improvement team is generally ready to examine curriculum issues and the implications of research and "best practices" to improve learning for all students. The RTC provides regional access to developmental academies to increase instructional staffs’ skills and ability to influence child-centered practices. Teaching staffs are provided with skill development sessions in the use of child-development and relationship theories and principles that promote academic achievement and psycho-social functioning for all children.


EMU faculty, student teachers, pre-student teachers, and social work and nursing student interns participate in many components of the Comer Project. Students and faculty represent every department in the College of Education, the Departments of Mathematics and Communication and Theater Arts in the College of Arts and Sciences, and the Departments of Nursing and Social Work in the College of Health and Human Services. EMU faculty are involved in a variety of ways-coordinating parent facilitators, supervising student teachers, directing internships and practicum projects, mentoring and providing staff development workshops and consultation to teachers and administrators. Participating faculty include the Comer philosophy and framework in undergraduate and graduate course work, and students gain valuable field experience through pre-student teaching or internships in Detroit Comer schools. The involvement of a diverse group of EMU faculty signifies a strong EMU commitment to the Detroit Comer Project. The University's involvement will continue as the Comer process becomes an integral part of its academic programs and practices.

What is the Yale Child Study Center School Development Program?

The Yale Child Study Center School Development Program (SDP) is a comprehensive school improvement model that is an organizational and management system designed to promote school change. SDP utilizes mechanisms that allow parents and staff to engage in processes in which they gain and apply knowledge of systems, child development, and of individual behavior to every aspect of a school program in a way and at a rate that is understandable and not threatening. The program is often referred to as the Comer School Development Program (SDP), or Comer Project, named after its founder, Dr. James P. Comer. Dr. Comer is the Maurice Falk Professor of Child Psychiatry at the Yale University Child Study Center, Associate Dean of the Yale University School of Medicine, and the first holder of the John W. Porter Endowed Chair for Urban Education at Eastern Michigan University. Dr. Comer established the school development model in 1968 in two elementary schools as collaboration between Yale University Child Study Center and New Haven Public Schools.

The School Development Program (SDP) is both a comprehensive school improvement model and the organizational entity at Yale Child Study Center charged with implementing the Comer Process in school communities. SDP differs from other school improvement programs in at least three significant ways. First, most give special attention to one major group within the school setting-either the students, or the teachers or the parents. SDP uses a comprehensive approach to school management in which all constituent groups work in a collaborative manner, coordinating resources and programs to establish and achieve school objectives and goals that lead to improved educational outcomes for all students.

Second, other school improvement programs are not rooted in child development, human development and relationship concepts. All aspects of the work of SDP are driven by relationship and child development theories focusing most on institutional practices that hinder adequate functioning of all members of the school community.
Third, many programs focus exclusively on cognitive development of the student or the academic program of the school. SDP attempts to create a school climate that permits parents and staff to support the overall development of all students in a way that makes academic achievement and desirable social behavior possible and expected. The Comer process is not a "quick fix" nor is it an "add on." It is not just another new activity to be carried out along with other experiments and activities already underway in the school.
The Comer process uses its nine-element process as a different way of conceptualizing and working in schools that completely replaces traditional school organization and management. All the activities in a Comer school are managed through the School Development process. Most importantly, SDP produces desirable results only after a cooperative and collaborative spirit exists throughout the school. The Comer School Development Program is a model that consists of the following components:
  • 3 mechanisms – the governance and management team, a mental health or student support team and a parent program
  • 3 operations - a comprehensive school plan, staff development, assessment and modification
  • 3 guiding principles - collaboration, consensus decision-making and no-fault problem-solving

Three Mechanisms

The Governance and Management Team where adult caretakers, i.e., teachers, parents, administrators and support staff, come together to pool their wisdom to plan the academic, social and staff development programs of the school designed to improve teaching and learning.
A Mental Health or Student Support Team coordinates and integrates the work of the mental health personnel within the school. It serves to prevent potential problems from developing into crises and to intervene in specific cases referred by teachers, other staff or parents.

The Parent Program provides an opportunity for parents to get involved in three major ways: on the governance and management team and subcommittees; as a parent group or team working with the staff to plan and support academic and social programs of the school; and as participants in various school events. The primary objective of the parent program is to create a climate of relationships among parents, staff and students, and to achieve a greater parent presence in the school that will lead to improved academic performance of all students.

Three Operations

The Comprehensive School Plan document is a written plan of action that outlines specific goals and objectives for the academic, staff and parent development, social and public relations programs of the school.

Staff development activities are based on the training and information needs of staff and parents which grow out of the building level goals and activities in support of academic excellence and social development of students.

Periodic assessment allows staff to modify the programs and activities of the school to meet identified needs and opportunities.

Three Guiding Principles

The principal and team members agree to collaborate. Members on the governance and management team agree to operate in a manner that does not paralyze the principal and the principal agrees that the group will not be used to "rubber stamp."

Decisions are made by consensus to avoid winner / loser behaviors and to allow and encourage maximum participation of all members of the teams.

A no fault, problem-solving approach is used by all working groups within the school. The groups agree to avoid blaming, faultfinding behavior and to concentrate on finding solutions to problems faced by students and the school.

Which schools are involved?

DETROIT COMER SCHOOLS


Cycle 1 Schools-1994 (The Skillman Foundation)

John F. Bennett Elementary School
Beulah Cain Brewer Elementary School
Samuel Gompers Elementary School
Greenfield Park Elementary School
James Vernor Elementary School
Augusta B. Woodward Elementary School

Cycle 2 Schools-1995 (The Skillman Foundation)
Bethune Duffield Elementary School
Peter G. Monnier Elementary School
Louis Pasteur Elementary School
Zina Pitcher Elementary School
Fannie Richards Elementary School

Cycle 3 Schools-1996 (The Skillman Foundation)
Ella Fitzgerald Elementary School
Arthur Logan Holmes Elementary School
Anthony Wayne Elementary School

Cycle 4 Schools-1997 (The Skillman Foundation)
Ernest J. Dossin Elementary School
Frederick H. Higgins Elementary School
A. Douglas Jamieson Elementary School
Ferdinand Foch Elementary School

Comprehensive School Reform Demonstration (CSRD)
Angelique Beaubien Middle School
T. Dale Cooke Elementary School
Jane Cooper Elementary School
Grayling Elementary School
Albert McMichael Middle School

Schools of the 21st Century
Academy of the Americas
Frank Beard Elementary School
John A. Logan Elementary School

Comprehensive School Reform Demonstration (CSRD)
Carstens Elementary School
Western International High School

Detroit Public Schools Title One
William Beckham Academy
Catherine Blackwell Elementary School
Cooley High School
Burbank Middle School
Farwell Middle School
Jordan Elementary School
Marion Law Academy
Lessenger Middle School
Macomb Elementary School
Nolan Middle School
Rosa Parks Middle School
Clara Rutherford Elementary School

back to top

Will there be opportunities for other schools to participate?

The Comer School Development Program was implemented in 26 Detroit schools as part of the Comer Schools and Families Initiative funded by The Skillman Foundation. These schools entered the initiative in five cycles between 1994 and 1999. In 1999, Detroit Public Schools system focused their efforts toward district-wide transformation of all of its schools into learner centered, caring organizations. Funding for this district-wide reform came from a variety of sources. Between 1999 and 2001 another 20 Detroit schools selected the Comer SDP as their school reform model and joined the Comer SDP initiative. In partnership with Detroit Public Schools and Eastern Michigan University, Yale Child Study Center established a Regional Training Center (RTC) to support faithful replication of SDP model within Detroit Public Schools and beyond Detroit’s metropolitan area. Currently (May-2002), the regionally managed training center supports implementation of the Comer SDP model in school communities in Pontiac and Grand Rapids, Michigan; Denver, Colorado; Springfield and Youngstown, Ohio. Several more school districts in Michigan are actively seeking to become Comer schools.

Evaluations and Awards

Samuel Gompers Elementary School in Detroit, MI serves 98% poverty population. In 1999, 80% of the students passed the fourth-grade Michigan Educational Assessment Program (MEAP) test in reading and science, and 100% passed in mathematics. In 2000, they achieved the highest WAP test scores among elementary schools in their size category in the state.



For Additional Information Contact:
Dr. Nora Martin, University Coordinator
Eastern Michigan University
Comer Schools and Families Initiative
104 Porter Building
Ypsilanti, MI 48197
Phone: (734) 487-6837
Fax: (734) 487-3312