Criteria for Evaluating Resources
(Internet- and Print-Based)
A2BCD
|
Authority of Source |
- Is a personal or organizational author identified?
- Does the author provide contact information, e.g., e-mail address,
telephone number, street address?
- Does the personal author provide any credentials...
- organizational affiliation?
- education?
- occupation?
- years of experience?
Do the credentials suggest an inherent bias or particular point of view?
- Is the author the creator of the document or a compiler of information
resources?
- Can you find other material by or about the author, either on
the Internet or using library resources, e.g., reference materials
or indexing publications?
|
Accuracy |
- Are the sources of facts documented?
- Are there links to the documented sources?
- Are the links relevant?
- Do the links work or are they broken?
- Can you corroborate the facts, either using Internet sources
or using library resources, e.g., reference materials or indexing publications?
- Has the author put in the effort to use good grammar and correct
spelling?
|
Bias/point of View |
- What is the purpose of the document...
- to inform/explain?
- to persuade/advocate a position?
- to sell?
Does this reflect a particular bias in viewpoint?
- Who is the intended audience, e.g., professionals, students,
consumers, advocates, etc.?
Does this affect the scope or bias of the information presented?
- Does the author distinguish facts from opinions?
- Are sources or viewpoints missing that you might expect to be
present?
|
Currency |
- When was the document created and when was it last
updated? (This is often specified at the end of the document.)
|
Design/Site Navigation |
- Do pages take a long time to load?
- Is the site well organized and logically arranged?
- Can you navigate the site without confusion?
- Is the text easy to read against the background?
- Are links helpful and relevant?
- Do graphics enhance (or distract from) the utility of the site?
|
Evaluating
Web Content (University of Albany)
Webliographies of sites that discuss the evaluation of Internet
resources
http://www.lib.vt.edu/help/instruct/evaluate/evalbiblio.html
http://www.vuw.ac.nz/~agsmith/evaln/evaln.htm
|
Last Updated:
January 10, 2008
Contact: Keith Stanger, keith@stanger.com |