EMU Linguistics Program

2004 Graduate Research Fair

Brit Klanert

Floating Quantifiers

Floating quantifiers are interesting in that they are able to change their position within a sentence without changing the meaning of that sentence, or so that is the assumption of the leading theories of Dominique Sportiche (1988) and others.

1) a. All the students have finished the assignment.
b. The students have all finished the assignment.

These examples, while different in the position of "all" (the floating quantifier), are identical in meaning.However, in my research I have discovered data that show an alternation of the meaning of a sentence after the quantifier "floated." The data taken into account by Sportiche and others does not consider cases in which the determiner phrase consists of a conjoined noun phrase as in (2).

2) a. All tigers, dogs and alligators have sharp teeth.
b. Tigers, dogs and alligators all have sharp teeth.

In addition, whether a definite article precedes the noun phrase plays an important role. In this presentation I will discuss the findings of my study on floating quantifiers with respect to the problems traced above. After outlining my data and establishing its relevance to current linguistic theories, I will consider a number of possible analyses of the data and show their strengths and weaknesses.

Close window